Is It Too Early To Allow Robotaxi On The Roads?

A traffic accident in San Francisco this week has put serious doubt on whether the local government made the right decision to allow Robotaxis on public roads. A hit-and-run incident that left a pedestrian gravely injured in the city is raising questions about whether autonomous vehicles (AVs) can handle the unexpected as well as, or better than, human drivers. We actually posted a story about a grassroots movement rebelling against robotaxis in late August. And it appears that this issue keeps going from bad to worse.

The incident involved both a human-driven car—which made the initial impact with the pedestrian—and a Cruise AV, which then also struck the victim a second time. According to the company, the pedestrian in question stepped onto the roadway from the right, crossing the path of the approaching robotaxi, which was already tracking her movements using its multiple cameras. She had cleared the right lane where the robotaxi was traveling and was almost halfway across the intersection when she was struck by the human-driven car in the left lane. After the initial impact, she was flung back into the right lane, where she was run over by the robotaxi.

Driverless cars need to do three things: See their environment, predict what’s about to happen, and decide what to do. Prediction is the most challenging aspect because AVs lack the instincts to foresee an outcome when compared to a human driver.

The expectation that driverless cars will be safer than cars driven by humans is basically the selling point of this technology. But as they roll out in more and more cities, a strong of accidents in cities like San Francisco and Austin has put the public on edge.

And this most recent incident is likely going to exacerbate that lack of trust, regardless of who is to blame. And it begs the question, would a human driver have behaved differently? Video footage shows the pedestrian in the crosswalk being struck by a human-driven car, then bouncing off that car’s windshield and into the path of the robotaxi.

In a statement, Cruise said its robotaxi “braked aggressively to minimize the impact” but was unable to stop before rolling over the woman and coming to a halt. Police are still investigating the cause of the accident, but their main witness could wind up being the robotaxi itself.

Several questions have arisen. Even though its lane was clear, should the Cruise vehicle have been more cautious, knowing a pedestrian was crossing against the light on a busy street at night? 

“When you see something bad happening on the road, a reasonable driver would slow down as a precaution,” said AV expert Philip Koopman, an associate professor at Carnegie Mellon University. “A reasonable driver doesn’t say, ‘That’s not my problem. I’m just gonna keep going.’”

Self-driving cars can only make decisions based on what they’re programmed to do. AVs aren’t coded “to anticipate a human projectile coming from the other way,” said Jennifer Dukarski, a Michigan lawyer specializing in AVs.

OUR THOUGHTS

To be honest, I’m not surprised at this outcome. It had to happen. But is there a solution? Maybe. Instead of being based on lines of code with specific instructions for a set of possible scenarios, the latest version of Tesla’s “Full Self-Driving” technology is teaching itself how to drive by processing billions of frames of video of how humans actually drive and using AI to do it. There’s almost an infinite list of things that can happen on the road — which is why teaching AVs to prepare for the unexpected is so difficult. And because of that, I don’t believe we will see AVs used in mass on public roads in my lifetime.

More Articles for You

It’s Cheaper Than A Tesla, Better Looking Than A Tesla And Has over 200K Bookings Already

Xiaomi is well-known in China and abroad for its range of hair dryers and smart air-conditioners but the influential corporation …

Iconic British Sports Car Company Reborn After Shutting Down 20 Years Ago

A well-known British sports car brand, thought to be extinct, has just been resurrected. Marcos Motor Company Ltd, which owns …

New Mercedes-Benz G580 Electric Debuts In Malaysia

Mercedes-Benz Malaysia (MBM) has unveiled the electric version of the Mercedes-Benz G580, featuring EQ Technology. If you want the G580 …

Design Legend Ian Callum Creates MINI Masterpiece For David Gandy

You hear the name Ian Callum and many car nuts immediately think of Jaguar, where Callum was design director for …

Bring Back Buttons And Switches Says UK’s Start Rescue

Are you like me? Do you lean towards dashboards with physical buttons? Especially cockpits with an audio volume button and …

Texas Puts Pressure On Tesla Robotaxi Rollout In Austin

Robotaxi is go. In certain areas of Austin, Texas, Tesla’s robotaxi service has commenced operations by providing invite-only trips to …